I have seen loads of unicorn cupcakes all over pinterest and they all look so amazing. I have always fancied trying to make my own but I’m not a very good baker. The kids love baking and wish I would do it more often with them, so last Sunday we spent the day making loads of different cupcakes and I had a go at making some unicorn cupcakes.
They turned out better than I expected, but nothing like the stunning creations I have seen online. But most of them you need to be an expert baker, which of course I am not. So these cupcakes are for the absolutely beginner like me. This follows a really easy to make cake batter and the way I made the buttercream frosting is easy.
Ok, I must admit, I did try to pipe the butter cream frosting and make those gorgeous magical swirls, but it just turned out a big mess with it all looking rather sloppy.


This cupcake mixture will make 24 cupcakes:
For the cake mixture :
- 250g butter
- 250g caster sugar
- 250g self-raising flour
- pinch of salt
- 4 medium eggs
- 4 tbsp of milk
- Food colouring of your choice – I used Dr Oetker gel in blue, purple and pink
- Set the oven to Gas mark 5
- Beat the butter until softened. Then add the sugar, flour, salt, eggs and milk and whisk until smooth.
- Divide the mixture between 2-3 bowls, depending on how many different colours you want. Add some gel food colouring, a different colour to each bowl. mix until you get the desired colour you want.
- Layer the mixtures into cupcake cases and place on two baking tray/muffin trays.
- Bake in the oven for 15 minutes then swap the tray positions and bake for a further 3-7 minutes.
Allow to cool completely. While they are cooling you can make your frosting and unicorn ears etc.
To make the unicorn and ears:
- White ready to roll frosting
- Dr Oetker silver Shimmer Spray.
- Pull a small ball of frosting of the block and roll in a ball until nice and soft. Split into two and roll both pieces out with your fingers to make two small unicorn shape pieces. Pinch the bottoms together and twist around each other making it into a point. Leave aside to harden.
- For the ears, do the same again and make a small ball and split in half. Make two ear shape pieces. I tried to make mine like a triangle then shape the bottom into a curve. leave to harden.
- Once hardened, place on to of foil or baking parchment and spray with the shimmer spray.
For the butter cream frosting:
- 1 part butter
- 3 parts icing sugar
- 1 tsp vanilla extract
- Food colouring of choice – I used Dr Oetker blue. purple and pink
- Mix the butter in an electric whisker until soft. (you can also do this by hand)
- Add the sugar and mix on a slow speed
- Add the vanilla. Then turn up high and mix for 5 minutes.
- Separate the mixture into bowls and add food colouring until you get your desired colour.
When the cupcakes have cooled completely down, add a blob of each different colour butter cream on top of each other and slightly mix together. Add the unicorn horn and ears. I then used blue and pink balls from the Dr Oetker superheros and fairy princess sprinkles set. I also added little pink hearts from the fairy princess sprinkle set and placed in the ears. I finished off with spraying the whole cupcake with the silver shimmer spray to give it a more magical feel.




Easy To Make Unicorn Cupcakes
These Unicorn Cupcakes are really easy to make and great for the beginner baker
For the Cupckaes
- 250 g butter
- 250 g caster sugar
- 250 g self-raising flour
- pinch of salt
- 4 medium eggs
- 4 tbsp of milk
- Food colouring of choice ( I used Dr Oetker blue. purple and pink)
For the Unicorn horn and ears
- White ready to roll frosting
- Dr Oetker silver Shimmer Spray.
For the buttercream frosting
- 1 part butter
- 3 parts icing sugar
- 1 tsp vanilla extract
- Food colouring of choice ( I used Dr Oetker blue. purple and pink)
To Make the Cupcakes
- Set the oven to Gas mark 5
- Beat the butter until softened. Then add the sugar, flour, salt, eggs and milk and whisk until smooth.
- Divide the mixture between 2-3 bowls, depending on how many different colours you want. Add some gel food colouring, a different colour to each bowl. mix until you get the desired colour you want.
- Layer the mixtures into cupcake cases and place on two baking tray/muffin trays.
- Bake in the oven for 15 minutes then swap the tray positions and bake for a further 3-7 minutes.
- Allow to cool completely. While they are cooling you can make your frosting and unicorn ears etc.
To Make the Unicorn Horn and Ears
- Pull a small ball of frosting of the block and roll in a ball until nice and soft. Split into two and roll both pieces out with your fingers to make two small unicorn shape pieces. Pinch the bottoms together and twist around each other making it into a point. Leave aside to harden.
- For the ears, do the same again and make a small ball and split in half. Make two ear shape pieces. I tried to make mine like a triangle then shape the bottom into a curve. leave to harden.
- Once hardened, place on to of foil or baking parchment and spray with the shimmer spray.
To Make the Buttercream Frosting
- Mix the butter in a electric whisker until soft. (you can also do this by hand)
- Add the sugar and mix on a slow speed
- Add the vanilla. Then turn up high and mix for 5 minutes.
- Separate the mixture into bowls and add food colouring until you get your desired colour.
- When the cupcakes have cooled completely down, add a blob of each different colour butter cream on top of each other and slightly mix together. Add the unicorn horn and ears. I then used blue and pink balls from the Dr Oetker superheros and fairy princess sprinkles set. I also added little pink hearts from the fairy princess sprinkle set and placed in the ears. I finished off with spraying the whole cupcake with the silver shimmer spray to give it a more magical feel.
These cupcakes may not look like the most beautiful unicorn cupcakes in the world, but I think I did a pretty good job. They tasted really delicious too and they where all eaten within just 15 minutes. Why not give them ago yourself and let me know how you get on.

I received the Dr Oetker items in return for this post. All opinions are mine
Ooooo perfect Halloween treats
Well have a go and see
These look great – might be a good half term task 😀 xxx
They looks great and tasty and look homemade which I love
I’ve not seen the shimmer spray before, they look great!
These look pretty and tasty too my daughter Sheriah would love them
These look brilliant and very tasty.
These look great. Will need to give them a try
going to have a go at making these,
These look great, will have to have a go.
Devine – these will go down a storm for my neices birthday
amazing will have to give these a go!
These look lovely must try some
Natasha,
Fun, creative cupcakes that any little girl would love to have! Thanks for sharing.
Great! These unicorn cupcakes look so beautiful and tasty! Thank you.
These look great and so yummy 🙂
Cute cute cute!
I love all things unicorn! These look so delicious and so fun! Thanks for sharing and linking up with me.
Shelbee
http://www.shelbeeontheedge.com
Awwww these actually look super cute and I bet they were very tasty. I’m impressed by the colouring inside the actual cake. We’ve not tired anything like this before but I’d like to. Thank you for sharing your goodies over on the #DreamTeamLinky xxx
Will certainly be giving these a go, looks delicious
Looks so tasty! I can’t wait to give it a try soon. By the way, I appreciate the reading. I have pleased to read the entirety of the post as mentioned above in detail. Thanks!
Oh, what a cute and yummy idea!! Thanks so much for linking up at the Unlimited Link Party 80. Pinned.
So fun!! I love these (and I’m an old lady!! LOL). Thanks for sharing at My Big Fat Menopausal Life’s Share the Wealth Party. Hope to see you there at the new party tomorrow.
These are adorable! Thanks for sharing at Vintage Charm!
Those are so cute!
I like the look of the different colour layers of sponge cake!
my granddaughter is unicorn mad so she will love these#ssp269
Beautifully done. Thank you from your SSPS Team for sharing your links with us at #269 SSPS Linky. If you have not shared your IG and FB URL and handles, please email me at esme@esmesalon.com as I am creating a database as you share your links with SSPS.
This way I can more easily tag you when you’re in the top 5 and I promote your post. Thanks in advance
What a great idea. And I’ve got to tell you, you did the icing decoration perfectly.
I appreciate you sharing this recipe with Sweet Tea & Friends this month dear friend.
Super cute! Thanks for sharing! My daughter will love these. Thank you for linking up with TTMT
just gorgeous!